Who We Are

Advertisement

WHO WE ARE: A festival of failure

To learn which city is better -- Melbourne or Sydney, go to Who We Are
For regular updates on Australian attitudes, bookmark http://blogs.sunherald.com.au/whoweare.

A column about Australia by David Dale, published in The Sun-Herald, 23/3/2008
Now is not the time to be urging a new hall of fame for Australia. The poverty-stricken federal government, faced with a surplus of only $18 billion, has cancelled funding promised by the previous government for a Fishing Hall of Fame and a Rugby League Hall of Fame. They will not join the Sports Hall of Fame (Melbourne); the Stockman's Hall of Fame (Longreach, Queensland); the Prospectors and Miners Hall of Fame (Kalgoorlie, WA); and the Shearer's Hall of Fame (Hay, NSW) in celebrating rare Australian achievements.

But what, we wonder, might be the government's reaction to the notion of a Hall of Failure? Surely we can learn as much about the national psyche from the things that Australians refuse to do as from the things they do. And Australia is often described as a land that loves its losers - a national song about a suicidal sheep rustler, making a hero of a horse thief hanged after bungling a bank robbery, a public holiday for a military fiasco, etc.

th_bobbyflynn.jpg My inspiration comes from an institution I visited a few years back in the town of Naples, New York - The Museum of Failed Products. For 30 years a marketing expert named Robert McMath has been collecting the offcuts of capitalism - wondrous potions, gadgets and taste treats that were launched with the highest hopes, only to be spurned by the customers and fade into oblivion.

McMath showed me hair shampoos called A Touch of Yoghurt and Gimme Cucumber; beverages called Panda Punch, Wallaby Squash, and Afrokola (a copy of Coke for black people); instant meals for lonely people, called Singles; green potato chips called "I Hate Peas"; and personal care products described as "edible deodorant" and "spray-on toothpaste".

th_dancingwiththestars.jpg He even shows a jar of Vegemite, the subject of a brief promotional campaign 20 years ago in America, but rejected as "too foreign-tasting".

So what might be on display in Australia's equivalent? We need look no further than the back catalogue of a company called K-Tel Products, which had huge success during the 1970s with the Feathertouch Knife, the Brush-o-Matic, the Record Selector, the Dial-o-Matic vegetable slicer and the Fishin' Magician. I asked Ken McDonald, the Managing Director at the time, to reveal his worst sellers. He chose three:

sit_howardapec.jpg The Deggorator, which required you to place a boiled egg in a little lathe and turn a handle so a row of pens painted designs on the egg. Australians preferred chocolate eggs at Easter.

The Single Knitting Needle, a kind of crochet hook designed to let a woman knit with one hand and hold a cup of tea with the other. You needed a PhD in structural engineering to use it.

The Pop-up Cigarette Dispenser, which clung to your car dashboard. It had sold well in Canada, but in our climate, the plastic would melt and buckle, so the device delivered S-shaped cigarettes.

If you have kept any of these devices from the golden age of gadgetry, or if you'd like to suggest other candidates for Australia's Hall of Lame -- products, people or proposals, tell us below.

We might be able to launch this project without government help. And if nobody comes to visit our museum, we can say it's an exhibit in itself.

David Dale is the author of Who We Are -- A snapshot of Australia today (Allen and Unwin). To discuss Australian attitudes, go to http://blogs.sunherald.com.au/whoweare.

COMMENTS

As your photo suggests, the museum should be officially opened by J. W.Howard

  • by Kenny on March 23, 2008 at 05:40 AM

If you want to get into the museum business, you really should know something about history first. Ned Kelly never bungled any robbery of any bank. Every one of his robberies was so successful that not a single shot was ever fired. His was hung after trying something different. Gallipoli was a military fiasco, but that was the fault of the English, not Australians. It is not remembered for being an example of what losers Australians are. There is a different message there. As for the suicidal sheep thief, that story has more in common with Japanese kamikaze polites than it does with celebrating loserdom. It is an example of someone putting death before surrender as a mark of their conviction.

DD replies: Fair enough. So what should go in the Museum of Failure?

  • by stompie on March 23, 2008 at 10:51 AM

You could put the NSW government in!

  • by Telemeister on March 23, 2008 at 11:53 AM

The Liberal and Labour Parties and almost forgot the Nationals, have failed the Australian people by continually selling our common wealth.
Things like the Commonwealth Bank, Telstra, the water and power utilities, putting tolls on our roads.
Not to mention not taxing foriegn corporations via the 1954 Double Taxation Act.
The fire sale of our natural resources.
But lastly the Australian people have failed by not demanding that the Commonwealth Constitution Act 1901 is upheld.
So in a nutshell the Constitution should be put in the Museum of failures as the checks and balances and speration of powers we were led to believe was part of that Constitution Act are an illusion that serves the political parties, their mates and fails the Australian people as a remedy to elitism.

  • by eagleman on March 23, 2008 at 12:10 PM

The submission of the Australian government to the control of foreign interests in the running of our once wonderful country. We are seeing and will soon see the full effects of this treacherous transaction!

  • by Rob on March 23, 2008 at 01:34 PM

How about the Defence Dept for every stuff up in equipment purchasing for the Army, Navy and Airforce over the last 30 years?

  • by Hunter on March 23, 2008 at 01:37 PM

Lord Doona of the Fishnets, Count Ygor Ruddock and Dame Amanda Fatstone would make a nice triptych.
...but I guess I'd have to vote for Eddie McGuire.

  • by Bill C. on March 23, 2008 at 02:01 PM

The Bondi Beach subway, which after 100 years finally made it to Bondi Junction but not a metre further or perhaps NSW State Rail in general, where 40 years ago the fastest train from Sydney to Newcastle took 1 hour 58 minutes and now the fastest train takes 2 hour 36 minutes. So when it was recently announced that State Rail would be building a $12 billion metro to the northern suburbs as only one arm of a four armed plan, we all knew that we were being sold yet another lame duck.

  • by Stephen on March 23, 2008 at 02:16 PM

Not in any order but here's a few that spring to mind.
Multi Function Polis
Any movie that Mel Gibson has been associated
Cross city tunnel...vacant
Fox Studios...flopperoo
Wonderland...???
Darling Harbour...who goes there
Star City casino...full of losers
Peter Costello...no mettle
Big Brother
McMansions...ugly as
Most Grafitti...ditto and poor art
Stubbie Holders...who drinks that slow
Last but not least is the Mit/Pad used by personal trainers,trying to hit as hard as possible the boxing gloves of people trying to get fit in peaceful public spaces.

  • by SBW on March 23, 2008 at 05:53 PM

City Rail NSW. What a joke!

  • by Richard on March 23, 2008 at 07:05 PM

The Oath of Allegiance and Ricky Ponting. OK, and Dannii Minogue

  • by BeingB on March 23, 2008 at 08:39 PM

How about the Sea-Sprite helicopters?

  • by David Barrott on March 23, 2008 at 09:37 PM

Tcard
Kraft Vegemite Cheese Singles
"World Sevens" rugby league tournament
Adelaide Rams, Western Reds, Sth Qld Crushers, the entire NBL, various NSL clubs
Bond Corp
Monorail
Private equity takeover bid for Qantas (photo of Dixon & Jackson laughing/hugging could be a feature of the museum)
Various TV shows that have lasted less than 4 episodes
Jeff Fenech's rugby league 'career'
All Big Brother contestants
And surely a section for al the "bigs" - banana, merino, pineapple etc

  • by Josh on March 23, 2008 at 09:56 PM

Museum fossils worth 'stuffing' :Germaine Greer, Paul Keating and Gough Whitlam.
House hold objects: (1) Those kitchen vertical grillers that were smoky and dirty; (2)Kitchen asbestos mats (for under saucepans) to stop custards and sauces burning (3) Kerosene in-house floor heaters

  • by Pat Walsh on March 23, 2008 at 10:57 PM

Gough Whitlam.

  • by Tim on March 23, 2008 at 11:17 PM

Anyone who takes themselves too seriously - which includes myself and all of the above but not DD

  • by Ian G on March 24, 2008 at 01:11 AM

I agree that Gough and Paul should be immortalised...

  • by BeingB on March 24, 2008 at 07:42 AM

Kyle and Jackie O. And please don't allow them to leave the museum. EVER!

  • by ilovetheinternet on March 24, 2008 at 08:46 AM

What are kerosene in-house floor heaters ?

Daryl Somer's joke book.

  • by Cranky Pants on March 24, 2008 at 09:34 AM

Becoming the clever country. We now have tradies, miners and baby boomer housing investors making a killing off of the Chinese and Indians becoming clever whilst our own clever people get abused at school and onward into life as the afore mentioned annihilates them financially.

  • by meathead nation on March 24, 2008 at 10:32 AM

Tony Barber albums

  • by Peter on March 24, 2008 at 11:30 AM

Yeah, Ned was definitely a loser. What else can you say about an Irishman that put an iron bucket on his head and thought himself bulletproof?
Other notables include the Leyland P76, the Chrysler/Mitsubishi car plant in Adelaide and Government Aircraft Factory 'Nomad'.

  • by Godot on March 24, 2008 at 11:47 AM

El-Hilali gets my vote.

  • by Frank Davie on March 24, 2008 at 12:09 PM

Adelaide

  • by barbarella on March 24, 2008 at 01:49 PM

City Rail, by virtue of its location, is a hopeless entity. Sydney is nowhere nearly densely populated enough to economically or logistically justify an effective metropolitan rail system. People compare City Rail to that of NY, London, Tokyo or Singapore. One cannot. In those cities, people live on top of each other, do not have cars and rely on rapid rail transport, which makes it economically and socially justified in plunging public resources in to creating, maintaining and improving such a system. In Australia, most households own cars and the decent suburbs are serviced by bus. The solution is to follow Harry Triguboff (see SMH October 11, 2006, "Triguboff: let's trade trees for homes") and create a city where everybody lives atop each other and does not have cars. There is always NZ if you need time out of civilisation.

  • by James Nakkan on March 24, 2008 at 01:56 PM

How about a museum of true stories told by Australian journalists, or aren't you interested in rarities?

  • by John on March 24, 2008 at 02:54 PM

John Howard
Workchoices

  • by Lina on March 24, 2008 at 06:20 PM

Amazing how this gets turned into anti-Howard dribble. Get over it fellas, he's gone.
Anyway, I think the museum should have a Leyland P76, A mitsubishi 380, Peter brock endorsed Lada's, a few copies of the Bulletin magazine and an AUSTEN sub machine gun.

  • by Marlon on March 24, 2008 at 09:15 PM

Have to take issue with the dork that nominated Germaine Greer ...she may go out on a limb sometime, or even fall off occasionally, but she actually changed the world for the better, and recently wrote one of the most fascinating books I've ever read about Shakespeare's England, which is more, I suspect, than Dorko's ever done.

  • by Bill C. on March 24, 2008 at 09:32 PM

I disagree with Stompie on all counts and here is the history he requested...
The Jolly Swagman was a loser because who would commit suicide just because they were busted stealing sheep? (Hardly a noble cause worthy of matyredom?)
Our celebration of the Anzacs focuses so heavily on the failure at Gallipoli that most Australians have never heard of General Monash or Albert Jacka, both heroes of WW1 who in different ways actually helped the Allies win the damn thing.
Ned Kelly had similair gripes to the American colonists before their revolution. But they successfully planned, preached and waged a military campaign against British rule which birthed a new nation...Ned puts a metal bucket on his head, shoots at a few cops and is quickly captured and hanged...hardly a good role model for those who actually want to win in life!
Yes DD we focus too much on the negatives in Australia and I'm glad you brought this up!!

  • by turncoat on March 24, 2008 at 11:51 PM

Peter Costello's ambitions to be Prime Minister of Australia

  • by Brett on March 25, 2008 at 02:46 AM

That spray on hair stuff.

  • by mike on March 25, 2008 at 09:20 AM

All volumes of poetry by John Laws. You know what I mean.

  • by Bereft Skerrick on March 25, 2008 at 02:53 PM

That amazing beer and wine bottle recycling device by KTel. You stuck the empty bottle in a holder, cut around the circumference and then (I forget how) joined the base to the bottle top to create a aweful looking vase that today would probably have real retro chic on a formica table top. (Blah!)

  • by Yuri on March 26, 2008 at 04:07 PM

In South Park last Monday, Stan's Grandad was using a "Deggorator".

  • by Unbeliever on March 26, 2008 at 05:43 PM

Throw in the Sydney big band, 'The K-Tels'. This band pays homage to all those terrible compilations of the K-Tel corporation ( remember 'Whopper', "Ripsnorter' and 'Teaser'?) by playing all those cheesy tunes. Problem is, they do it real well...

  • by CF on March 26, 2008 at 08:57 PM

by Yuri on March 26, 2008 at 04:07 PM

Gee, Yuri, I had a pair of wineglasses manufactured from a pair of stubbie beer bottles that I thought were so cool but it was the early 70's and I was very young and impressionable.

  • by Shoopie on March 29, 2008 at 12:55 PM

POST A COMMENT

Security code image.