Advertisement
It's not often a Pom finds cause for deep national pride at a sporting tournament, but my compatriot Lucy Fairbrother this week covered our nation in glory before the Games had even begun.
The unassuming 23-year-old was one of four demonstrators who defied draconian Chinese security to unfurl Tibetan flags and a banner from a 120 foot lighting pole at the Beijing Olympic Stadium on the eve of the opening ceremony.
They were arrested of course and subjected to an intimidating, shrill and 'surreal' interrogation by fist-thumping police officers in which Lucy was accused of 'plotting with the Dalai Lama.' These demonstrators were lucky compared to others who express dissent in China; they escaped with a scolding and swift deportation. Had they been Tibetan, the interrogation would have almost certainly have come complete with cattle prod, beatings and permanent residence in a prison cell. As Fairbrother herself pointed out on her return to England, "I was scared, but I tried to focus on the fact that whatever was happening to me was nothing compared to what some of my Tibetan friends had been through."
Quite rightly, Fairbrother has received a hero's welcome back home. It takes incredible guts to stage a stunt like that and I was reminded of this again a few days ago when I was privileged to talk to the team who carried out Australia's most dramatic pro-Tibet protest during the Olympic torch relay in April. These four covered the iconic Coke sign at Kings Cross with a banner bearing the slogan: Enjoy Compassion, Always Tibet. Images were broadcast around the world and it was one of the most powerful symbols of the relay's many protests.
Like Lucy Fairbrother, this group was arrested too but their treatment by Kings Cross police contrasted starkly with her ordeal in China. "The officers were firm but courteous and actually quite sympathetic as we had damaged nothing and hurt no-one," said one of the activists (whose identities I'm protecting). Last week, the four's charges of trespass were thrown out of court by a judge who conceded the group had merely been exercising their right to peaceful public protest. They were delighted but, like Lucy, also all too aware of how fortunate they were not to be Tibetans demonstrating in China (or Nepal, where hundreds of Tibetan protesters continue to be rounded up and beaten on a daily basis), for whom a similar act would most likely mean a long incarceration punctuated by regular bouts of torture.
I hope there are more brave Westerners out there ready to make a stand on behalf of Tibetans and I believe no athlete on the British team deserves more praise than Lucy and her plucky crew. They should receive an honorary gold medal.
And what of the opening ceremony? You'll probably be expecting me to bag it, but actually I thought it was brilliant. How could it not be, with a $300 million budget and the vision of top movie director Zhang Yimou? I enjoyed the show for the same reason I enjoy Zhang's hit films: they are spectacular, imaginative works of fiction. In my job as a party reporter I've seen no end of expensive, well-planned extravaganzas designed to showcase everything from shampoo to alcohol and I can testify more than most to the capacity of theatre to inspire. With the right budget and event planner and some clever artifice, you can convince an audience of the supremacy of just about any product you're trying to flog.
On Friday night, the product was modern China -and the glitzy, expensive movie version was certainly awe-inspiring. But once the show's over, reality remains and in China this means unsavoury everyday incidents such as the unexplained disappearance of the wife of jailed Chinese activist Zeng Jinyan the day before the Olympics began, and today's detention of Chinese Christian activist Hua Huiqi. Then there was the ugly manhandling by police of protester Christina Chan in Hong Kong on Saturday.
But the Olympics so far haven't been without a laugh or two. As always, George Bush injected a shot of unintentional farce into the proceedings by lumbering around yesterday with female beach volleyballers like a sweaty park pest. And proving that even in matters of serious protest we Poms are still the masters of daftness, British protester Matt Pearce climbed up Hong Kong's Tsing Yi bridge on Friday in a horse costume, carrying a guitar, to protest about human rights. Not quite as effective as Lucy Fairbrother's statement, but it couldn't have been easy (horse costumes are usually for two people, aren't they?) and at least his heart was in the right place.
Amy, this is a great overview of the many different kinds of human rights abuses that face Tibetans and Chinese, which the world can already see even in the first few days of China's totalitarian makeover of the Olympic Games. Compared to Chinese Christians, however, the Tibetan people face additional challenges in that the Chinese Communists have created a system that treats them as colonial subjects. (Scholars in Marxism will recall that Tibet never attained the status of a Soviet under Mao, because he already foresaw the potential of Tibet to be turned into the standing reserve of China's expansionist industrialism.) Instead Tibetan is a nationality in its own right, not an ethnic minority as China tells the world. Until this is recognised by the Chinese, the Tibetans will always be shortchanged in any dialogue even well-meaning Chinese try to establish with them. The basis of a mutual recognition of each other's independent nationality, hence non-interchangeable identity, is necessary for the establishment of a meaningful and enduring solidarity between the Tibetan and the Chinese victims of Chinese totalitarianism.
As to the opening ceremony itself, its emphasis on martial might reminds one of Mao's fascination for the Emperor of Qin (259-210 BCE), whose obsession with terracotta warriors spoke loudly of his imperialist understanding of the afterlife. It was this same emperor who had multitudes of scholars buried alive in order to quell dissent. Why no emphasis on justice, fairness and forbearance, which are integral to traditional Chinese philosophy, in the opening ceremony parades, which will resonate far better with classical Olympic ideals? Instead one sees a postmodern appropriation of Emperor Qin's "tremendum" by Zhang Yimou, which bespeaks of an ambiguity that can be quite disturbing if further reflection is ventured. There is definitely no "fascinans" there for Tibetans to identify themselves with. Grandeur is alienating for the oppressed when the humdrum everyday in China is already mired in alienation.
Keep up the good work, Amy!
Olympics where many became(will) my hero not coz they won 'Gold or silver' but they stuck with under-dog (Tibet) and became a legend.
Legacy of Peter Norman will and should continue. Thank You Amy for bringing heroes to us!
The Chinese managed to avoid many embarrassing protests, although this one stood out like a sore thumb. She and the others did a great job of garnering attention to the issue.
When posting comments on blogs you agree to abide by our terms and conditions.
Comments that are offensive, defamatory, unsuitable or that breach any aspects of the terms will be deleted.
Advertisement
| member centre | network map | mobile | advertise with us | place a classified ad |
The concerns on this side of the world in the UK are all about the war in Georgia where once again innocent civilians are being bombed out of their homes because of a few with an axe to grind. Then there are the terrible floods in Vietnam that have caused hardship and disaster to so many. The Olympics now they have begun may bring light relief to viewers and sports followers but do they have to cost so much to put on?? I hope London 2012 concentrates on sports facilities and a very simple opening ceremony, or maybe a rerun of the Edinburgh tattoo or the Lord Mayors Show.